2457 232nd Street, Cushing, WI 54006

New Listing
$544,000
Property Type: Residential Bedrooms: 1 Baths: 2 Square Footage: 2,602 Lot Size (sq. ft.): 109,336 Status: Active
Current Price: $544,000 List Date: 5/15/2026 Last Modified: 5/15/2026

Overview

Description

Set on 2.51 acres with an incredible 700 feet of level shoreline on McKeith Lake, this peninsula-like property is surrounded by water on three sides, creating the peaceful and private setting you feel the moment you arrive. This beautifully maintained log home offers a warm and inviting open-concept layout, highlighted by wood beams and a seamless flow between the kitchen, dining, and living spaces. The kitchen features granite countertops, black stainless steel appliances, and thoughtfully designed cabinetry with pull-out shelving for both style and function. Vaulted ceilings and expansive windows frame the lake and fill the home with natural light. The primary bedroom features its own private deck, an ideal place to take in the quiet beauty of the property. The spacious loft offers flexible guest sleep space or cozy retreat area, with abundant storage and potential for future bedroom conversion. The walkout lower level expands your living space with a 28x11 screened three-season porch with steel ceiling overlooking the lake, a large family room, bar, full bathroom with whirlpool tub, in-floor heat, laundry, utility room, and storage, making it both comfortable and functional. The spacious lower level layout also offers excellent potential for additional sleeping space or future bedroom conversion if desired. Step outside to enjoy the thoughtfully designed grounds, complete with walking paths winding through the property, including a charming hillside shed that has previously been used as a cozy bunkhouse for guests and currently offers additional storage. Spanning the lakeside length of the home, the expansive deck provides the perfect place to relax, entertain, and take in the beautiful views. Near the shoreline, the firepit area is perfectly positioned to create an ?infinity style? illusion overlooking the water, making it the ideal place to take in breathtaking sunsets and unforgettable evenings at the lake. A detached, insulated and sheet-rocked 3.5-car garage, 36x28, is set approximately 200 feet from the home, connected by a scenic path that enhances the sense of privacy and peaceful separation. A newly built storage shed near the garage provides even more storage space. Recent updates completed in 2025 include a new roof, skylight, and gutters on the home, along with a new roof and gutters on the garage. Additional improvements include a new furnace, water purifier, all lakeside windows and doors, and thoughtful updates throughout. With fiber optic internet, a functional mudroom entry, beautiful natural surroundings, and exceptional privacy, this property offers the perfect blend of modern comfort and peaceful lakeside living.

Listing Details MLS# 7073283

General Property Information

Common Wall
No
Lot Measurement
Acres
Manufactured Home?
No
Multiple PIDs?
No
New Development
No
Number of Fireplaces
Yes
Road Btwn WF & Home?
No
Waterfront Present
Yes
Year Built
2002
Yearly/Seasonal
Yearly
Zoning
Shoreline, Residential-Single Family
Bath Full
2
Main Floor Total SqFt
1048
Above Grd Total SqFt
1554
Below Grd Total SqFt
1048
Total SqFt
2602
Total Finished Sqft
2602.00
FireplaceYN
Yes
Lake/Waterfront Name
McKeith Lake
Style
(SF) Single Family
Foundation Size
1048
Garage Stalls
3.5
Lot Dimensions
566x106x789x444
Acres
2.51
Assessment Pending
Unknown
Bath Three Quarters
0
Bath Half
0
Bath Quarter
0
Association Fee
0

Property Features

Accessible: None Air Conditioning: Central Air Amenities Unit: Ceiling Fan(s); Deck; Dock; Kitchen Center Island; Kitchen Window; Main Floor Primary Bedroom; Natural Woodwork; Panoramic View; Porch; Skylight; Tile Floors; Vaulted Ceiling(s); Washer/Dryer Hookup Appliances: Dishwasher; Dryer; Fuel Tank - Rented; Microwave; Range; Refrigerator; Washer; Water Filtration System Basement: Full Bath Description: Main Floor Full Bath; Full Basement Construction Materials: Timber/Post & Beam Construction Status: Previously Owned Dining Room Description: Living/Dining Room Electric: 200+ Amp Service Elevation Highpoint to Waterfront Slope: Level Exterior: Log Family Room Characteristics: Lower Level Fireplace Characteristics: Family Room; Gas Burning Foundation: Permanent Fuel: Propane Heating: Forced Air; In-Floor Heating Internet Options: Fiber Optic Lake Details: Sand Laundry: Lower Level Lock Box Type: Combo Lot Description: Irregular Lot; Tree Coverage - Medium Outbuildings: Bunk House Parking Characteristics: Garage Door Opener Property Subtype: Loft; Log Home Road Frontage: Paved Streets; Township Road Responsibility: Public Maintained Road Roof: Age 8 Years or Less; Asphalt Shingles Sellers Terms: Cash; Conventional; FHA Sewer: Mound Septic; Septic System Compliant - Yes Special Search: Main Floor Primary Stories: One and One Half Water: Drilled Waterfront View: Lake; North; West

Contract Information

Contingency
None
Original List Price
544000
ListPrice
544000
Owner is an Agent?
No
Auction?
No

Location Tax and Other Information

House Number
2457
Street Name
232nd
Street Suffix
Street
Postal City
Cushing
County
Polk
State
WI
Zip Code
54006
Complex/Dev/Subdivision
Rollingwood Shores

Assessments

Tax With Assessments
4728
Assessment Balance
0

Basement

Foundation Dimensions
34x28x11x8
Full
Yes

More Information

Building Information

Finished SqFt Above Ground
1554
Finished SqFt Below Ground
1048

Elevation Highpoint to Waterfront Feet

Elevation Highpoint Waterfront Feet
0-4

Lake Details

Lake Acres
73
Lake Depth
8
Sand
Yes

Lease Details

Land Leased
Not Applicable

Miscellaneous Information

Homestead
Yes

Ownership

Fractional Ownership
No

Parking Characteristics

Garage Dimensions
36x28
Garage Square Feet
1008
Garage Door Opener
Yes

Public Survey Info

Range#
18W
Section#
31
Township#
36N

Office/Member Info

Association
WWRA

Location, Tax and Other Information

AssocFeeYN
No
Legal Description
LOT 19 PLAT OF ROLLINGWOOD SHORES
Listing City
Cushing
Map Page
999
Municipality
Cushing
School District
Luck
School District Phone
715-472-2151
DNR Lake ID#
2481500
DNR Lake Classification
Not Applicable
Zip Plus 4
3644
Property ID Number
030010051900
Tax Year
2025
Tax Amount
4728
In Foreclosure?
No
Potential Short Sale?
No
Lender Owned?
No

Directions & Remarks

Public Remarks
Set on 2.51 acres with an incredible 700 feet of level shoreline on McKeith Lake, this peninsula-like property is surrounded by water on three sides, creating the peaceful and private setting you feel the moment you arrive. This beautifully maintained log home offers a warm and inviting open-concept layout, highlighted by wood beams and a seamless flow between the kitchen, dining, and living spaces. The kitchen features granite countertops, black stainless steel appliances, and thoughtfully designed cabinetry with pull-out shelving for both style and function. Vaulted ceilings and expansive windows frame the lake and fill the home with natural light. The primary bedroom features its own private deck, an ideal place to take in the quiet beauty of the property. The spacious loft offers flexible guest sleep space or cozy retreat area, with abundant storage and potential for future bedroom conversion. The walkout lower level expands your living space with a 28x11 screened three-season porch with steel ceiling overlooking the lake, a large family room, bar, full bathroom with whirlpool tub, in-floor heat, laundry, utility room, and storage, making it both comfortable and functional. The spacious lower level layout also offers excellent potential for additional sleeping space or future bedroom conversion if desired. Step outside to enjoy the thoughtfully designed grounds, complete with walking paths winding through the property, including a charming hillside shed that has previously been used as a cozy bunkhouse for guests and currently offers additional storage. Spanning the lakeside length of the home, the expansive deck provides the perfect place to relax, entertain, and take in the beautiful views. Near the shoreline, the firepit area is perfectly positioned to create an ?infinity style? illusion overlooking the water, making it the ideal place to take in breathtaking sunsets and unforgettable evenings at the lake. A detached, insulated and sheet-rocked 3.5-car garage, 36x28, is set approximately 200 feet from the home, connected by a scenic path that enhances the sense of privacy and peaceful separation. A newly built storage shed near the garage provides even more storage space. Recent updates completed in 2025 include a new roof, skylight, and gutters on the home, along with a new roof and gutters on the garage. Additional improvements include a new furnace, water purifier, all lakeside windows and doors, and thoughtful updates throughout. With fiber optic internet, a functional mudroom entry, beautiful natural surroundings, and exceptional privacy, this property offers the perfect blend of modern comfort and peaceful lakeside living.
Directions
From St Croix, Hwy 87 Northwest to Cushing, East on Cty Rd N (250th), go one mile take a right on to 230th St, right on to 243rd Ave, right on to 232nd St to property on right.

Accessible

None
Yes

Air Conditioning

Central Air
Yes

Amenities Unit

Ceiling Fan(s)
Yes
Deck
Yes
Dock
Yes
Kitchen Center Island
Yes
Kitchen Window
Yes
Main Floor Primary Bedroom
Yes
Natural Woodwork
Yes
Panoramic View
Yes
Porch
Yes
Skylight
Yes
Tile Floors
Yes
Vaulted Ceiling(s)
Yes
Washer/Dryer Hookup
Yes

Appliances

Dishwasher
Yes
Dryer
Yes
Fuel Tank - Rented
Yes
Microwave
Yes
Range
Yes
Refrigerator
Yes
Washer
Yes
Water Filtration System
Yes

Bath Description

Main Floor Full Bath
Yes
Full Basement
Yes

Construction Materials

Timber/Post & Beam
Yes

Construction Status

Previously Owned
Yes

Dining Room Description

Living/Dining Room
Yes

Electric

200+ Amp Service
Yes

Elevation Highpoint to Waterfront Slope

Level
Yes

Exterior

Log
Yes

Family Room Characteristics

Lower Level
Yes

Fireplace Characteristics

Family Room
Yes
Gas Burning
Yes

Foundation

Permanent
Yes

Fuel

Propane
Yes

Heating

Forced Air
Yes
In-Floor Heating
Yes

Insurance Fee

Insurance Fee
0

Internet Options

Fiber Optic
Yes

Lake/Waterfront

Lake Front
Yes

Laundry

Lower Level
Yes

Lock Box Type

Combo
Yes

Lot Description

Irregular Lot
Yes
Tree Coverage - Medium
Yes

Outbuildings

Bunk House
Yes

Patio, Porch and Deck Features

Deck
Yes
Front Porch
Yes
Screened
Yes

Property Subtype

Loft
Yes
Log Home
Yes

Road Frontage

Paved Streets
Yes
Township
Yes

Road Responsibility

Public Maintained Road
Yes

Roof

Age 8 Years or Less
Yes
Asphalt Shingles
Yes

Sellers Terms

Cash
Yes
Conventional
Yes
FHA
Yes

Sewer

Mound Septic
Yes
Septic System Compliant - Yes
Yes

Special Search

Main Floor Primary
Yes

Stories

One and One Half
Yes

Water

Drilled
Yes

Waterfront View

Lake
Yes
North
Yes
West
Yes

Room Information

Bathroom Dimensions: 12x6.5 Level: Main Bathroom Dimensions: 9x6.5 Level: Lower Family Room Dimensions: 27x14 Level: Lower First (1st) Bedroom Dimensions: 14x13.5 Level: Main Kitchen Dimensions: 14x13 Level: Main Kitchen Dimensions: 9x7 Level: Lower Laundry Dimensions: 17x14 Level: Lower Living Room Dimensions: 28x14 Level: Main Loft Dimensions: 28x16 Level: Upper Mud Room Dimensions: 8x6.5 Level: Main
Listing Office: Outdoors Realty
IDX
Last Updated: May - 15 - 2026
The data relating to real estate for sale on this web site comes in part from the Broker Reciprocity SM Program of the Regional Multiple Listing Service of Minnesota, Inc. The information provided is deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Properties subject to prior sale, change or withdrawal. ©2024 Regional Multiple Listing Service of Minnesota, Inc All rights reserved.