1875 Pine Island Park Street, Balsam Lake, WI 54810

New Listing
$1,225,000
Property Type: Residential Bedrooms: 3 Baths: 2 Square Footage: 2,156 Lot Size (sq. ft.): 489,614 Status: Coming Soon
Current Price: $1,225,000 List Date: 5/11/2026 Last Modified: 5/13/2026

Overview

Description

Nestled along the shores of highly sought-after Boston Bay on Balsam Lake, this rustic retreat blends timeless cabin charm with thoughtful modern updates. Set on over 11 wooded acres with 115 feet of frontage on Balsam Lake, this cozy cabin in the woods offers privacy, tranquility, and endless possibilities. The property includes three parcel IDs, one of which is a separate 5-acre buildable lot. Originally built in 1965 and extensively remodeled in 2015, the home was lifted to add a new basement while nearly every aspect of the property was refreshed, including new windows, siding (treated with Ecowood to give the appearance of aged wood), septic system, mechanics, plumbing, wiring, kitchen, and beautiful rustic finishes throughout. Inside, you'll find warm character at every turn, from the custom reclaimed barnwood front door to the reclaimed wood kitchen cabinetry and stairway. Rustic 9” white pine plank flooring adds to the authentic Northwoods feel. The lower-level walkout leads directly to your peaceful lakeside setting, where a stunning dry creek bed flows from the rain garden, creating a truly serene outdoor environment.  A 2-car garage, also added in 2015, completes this exceptional lake property. If you’ve been searching for peaceful serenity on Balsam Lake, this is it.

Listing Details MLS# 7027560

General Property Information

Common Wall
No
Lot Measurement
Acres
Manufactured Home?
No
Multiple PIDs?
Yes
New Development
No
Road Btwn WF & Home?
No
Waterfront Frontage
115
Waterfront Present
Yes
Year Built
1965
Yearly/Seasonal
Yearly
Zoning
Lot, Shoreline, Residential-Single Family
Bath Full
Yes
Bath Three Quarters
Yes
Main Floor Total SqFt
1078
Above Grd Total SqFt
1078
Below Grd Total SqFt
1078
Total SqFt
2156
Total Finished Sqft
2020.00
FireplaceYN
No
Style
(SF) Single Family
Foundation Size
1078
Garage Stalls
2
Lot Dimensions
See CSM
Acres
11.24
Assessment Pending
Unknown
Number of Fireplaces
0
Bath Half
0
Bath Quarter
0
Association Fee
0

Property Features

Accessible: None Air Conditioning: Central Air Amenities Unit: Deck; Dock; Hardwood Floors; Main Floor Primary Bedroom; Natural Woodwork; Panoramic View; Washer/Dryer Hookup Appliances: Dishwasher; Dryer; Range; Refrigerator; Washer Assumable Loan: Not Assumable Basement: Full Bath Description: Main Floor Full Bath; 3/4 Basement Construction Materials: Timber/Post & Beam Construction Status: Previously Owned Dining Room Description: Eat In Kitchen Exterior: Metal; Wood Family Room Characteristics: Lower Level Foundation: Concrete Block Fuel: Propane Heating: Forced Air Internet Options: Fiber Optic Laundry: In Hall; Lower Level Lock Box Type: Combo Property Subtype: Acreage; Cabin; Ranch-Style Home Road Frontage: County Road Road Responsibility: Public Maintained Road Roof: Age Over 8 Years Sellers Terms: Cash; Conventional Sewer: Septic System Compliant - Yes; Tank with Drainage Field Special Search: Main Floor Primary Stories: One Water: Sand Point Waterfront View: West

Contract Information

Contingency
None
Original List Price
1225000
ListPrice
1225000
Owner is an Agent?
No
Auction?
No

Location Tax and Other Information

House Number
1875
Street Name
Pine Island Park
Street Suffix
Street
Postal City
Balsam Lake
County
Polk
State
WI
Zip Code
54810

Additional Parcels Information

Property ID #2
040011910001
Property ID #3
040011910500

Assessments

Tax With Assessments
5861
Assessment Balance
0
Assessment Installment
0

More Information

Building Information

Finished SqFt Above Ground
993
Finished SqFt Below Ground
1027

Lake Details

Lake Acres
1901
Lake Depth
37

Lease Details

Land Leased
Not Applicable

Miscellaneous Information

Homestead
No

Ownership

Fractional Ownership
No

Parking Characteristics

Garage Dimensions
24x24
Garage Square Feet
576

Public Survey Info

Range#
17W
Section#
35
Township#
35N

Office/Member Info

Association
WWRA

Location, Tax and Other Information

AssocFeeYN
No
Legal Description
LOT 1 CSM #6404 V29 PG 68 (824913) OF PT LOT 1 OF CSM #6029 V27 PG 93 (784931) LOC IN GOV LOT 3
Listing City
Balsam Lake
Map Page
999
Municipality
Balsam Lake
School District
Unity
School District Phone
715-825-3515
DNR Lake Classification
Not Applicable
Zip Plus 4
2951
Property ID Number
040011900000
Tax Year
2025
Tax Amount
5861
In Foreclosure?
No
Potential Short Sale?
No
Lender Owned?
No

Directions & Remarks

Public Remarks
Nestled along the shores of highly sought-after Boston Bay on Balsam Lake, this rustic retreat blends timeless cabin charm with thoughtful modern updates. Set on over 11 wooded acres with 115 feet of frontage on Balsam Lake, this cozy cabin in the woods offers privacy, tranquility, and endless possibilities. The property includes three parcel IDs, one of which is a separate 5-acre buildable lot. Originally built in 1965 and extensively remodeled in 2015, the home was lifted to add a new basement while nearly every aspect of the property was refreshed, including new windows, siding (treated with Ecowood to give the appearance of aged wood), septic system, mechanics, plumbing, wiring, kitchen, and beautiful rustic finishes throughout. Inside, you'll find warm character at every turn, from the custom reclaimed barnwood front door to the reclaimed wood kitchen cabinetry and stairway. Rustic 9” white pine plank flooring adds to the authentic Northwoods feel. The lower-level walkout leads directly to your peaceful lakeside setting, where a stunning dry creek bed flows from the rain garden, creating a truly serene outdoor environment.  A 2-car garage, also added in 2015, completes this exceptional lake property. If you’ve been searching for peaceful serenity on Balsam Lake, this is it.
Directions
From the town of Balsam Lake take Hwy 46 N to Right on 200th Ave to Right on 140th St to Right on Pine Island Park Street to the property on your Right. Long driveway to the lake.

Accessible

None
Yes

Air Conditioning

Central Air
Yes

Amenities Unit

Deck
Yes
Dock
Yes
Hardwood Floors
Yes
Main Floor Primary Bedroom
Yes
Natural Woodwork
Yes
Panoramic View
Yes
Washer/Dryer Hookup
Yes

Appliances

Dishwasher
Yes
Dryer
Yes
Range
Yes
Refrigerator
Yes
Washer
Yes

Assumable Loan

Not Assumable
Yes

Basement

Full
Yes

Bath Description

Main Floor Full Bath
Yes
3/4 Basement
Yes

Construction Materials

Timber/Post & Beam
Yes

Construction Status

Previously Owned
Yes

Dining Room Description

Eat In Kitchen
Yes

Exterior

Metal
Yes
Wood
Yes

Family Room Characteristics

Lower Level
Yes

Foundation

Concrete Block
Yes

Fuel

Propane
Yes

Heating

Forced Air
Yes

Insurance Fee

Insurance Fee
0

Internet Options

Fiber Optic
Yes

Lake/Waterfront

Lake Front
Yes

Laundry

In Hall
Yes
Lower Level
Yes

Lock Box Type

Combo
Yes

Patio, Porch and Deck Features

Deck
Yes

Property Subtype

Acreage
Yes
Cabin
Yes
Ranch-Style Home
Yes

Road Frontage

County Road
Yes

Road Responsibility

Public Maintained Road
Yes

Roof

Age Over 8 Years
Yes

Sellers Terms

Cash
Yes
Conventional
Yes

Sewer

Septic System Compliant - Yes
Yes
Tank with Drainage Field
Yes

Special Search

Main Floor Primary
Yes

Stories

One
Yes

Water

Sand Point
Yes

Waterfront View

West
Yes

Room Information

Family Room Dimensions: 16x13 Level: Lower First (1st) Bedroom Dimensions: 14x10 Level: Main Kitchen Dimensions: 17x9 Level: Main Laundry Dimensions: 6x3 Level: Lower Living Room Dimensions: 20x21 Level: Main Pantry (Walk-In) Dimensions: 6x5 Level: Main Second (2nd) Bedroom Dimensions: 18x15 Level: Lower Third (3rd) Bedroom Dimensions: 12x11 Level: Lower
Listing Office: Edina Realty, Inc.
IDX
Last Updated: May - 13 - 2026
The data relating to real estate for sale on this web site comes in part from the Broker Reciprocity SM Program of the Regional Multiple Listing Service of Minnesota, Inc. The information provided is deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Properties subject to prior sale, change or withdrawal. ©2024 Regional Multiple Listing Service of Minnesota, Inc All rights reserved.